Analyze self –plagiarism
INTRODUCTION
Academic standard have became more rigorous nowadays for
schools. Colleges, universities and schools have high standard for the students
to be educationally successful. However, constraints might affect the quality of
the education. For instance, one of the constraints that discovered last decades
and affect the education is self-plagiarism.
The goal of this report is to analyze self –plagiarism from
different types. For example, why self-plagiarism is significant issue, also
discussion and analysis academic and professional self-plagiarism finally,
professors, who had issues with their students that using the old files for
other students to do the assignments.
WHAT IS SELF-PLAGIARISM?
We might know the word self-plagiarism that is a huge topic
affect academic succeed and professional. Some people consider it the same as
cheating. The simple definition of self-plagiarism is when someone takes others
work and republished for his own words without reversing it or citation or take
a promotion. For that, students, employees and authors are included because
most of the self-plagiarism cases based on these three. Stephen Kobourov a head
of the computer science department talks about his experience in
self-plagiarism. He says: Some graduate students don’t know the basic of the
materials that we review in the class how could that possible happen? For
example, the graduate students must know the basic materials of undergraduate.
(Self –plagiarism in computer science 7)
Self –plagiarism could be in many terms. For example, duplicate
publication, copywriting infringement and IP protection. When we address
these issues many people would debate about self-plagiarism because, some of
them complain that is a huge problem in our society. In the other side of the
audiences, they do not see any problem with the term they see the opposite and
the easy way to take benefits from others ideas. The fact, for the huge debates
make the issue complicated. When we come to the subject why this issue is
complicated we realize how self -plagiarism affect the academic and
professional community. According to S, Mohapatra in article (“The ethics of self-plagiarism”). He says,
“ Some argue that self plagiarism involves dishonesty but not intellectual
theft”. For that, what we realize here the debate of the self-plagiarism
whether ethical or unethical will go on for a long time and make the issue
complicated.
Moreover, the audiences who take the fact that republished
someone ideas or steal that from him argued is unethical however, what kind of
constraint will be in term of academic succeed and professional?
In addition, the case is confusing for many audiences who
address the problem in the education field. Also, the professional field has
chance. Students and employees are Simultaneously involves in the case of the self-plagiarism.
In last decade, studies cases discover that most of the duplicate published
which is one of the types of self-plagiarism continuously increase year after
year.
In 1999, until now the cases of self-plagiarism has been
increasing quickly. The cases included all kinds of plagiarism like, copywriting
infringement and duplicate publication.
According to Mohapatra, Samel assistant
Professor (Animal Science) she researched about the biomedical journals and how
that related to the self - plagiarism. She says each term I expect three or
four cases of self –plagiarism in
the class. The students use old files to cover their assignments also, it might
be the same assignments from student who took the class before. “However, my belief that self-plagiarism is
detrimental to scientific progress and bad for our academic community “. She talked about her
experience and how is that affecting the academic career. The students use the
old materials but is that a solution to be succeed?
As she go a long with
the article the numbers of the students who cover the assignment with old
documents increased. For example, around 55 % of the class uses the old
materials. She compare how self –plagiarism can
be bad for the academic community when the students do a very well in the assignments
and homework however, in the exam you can’t image how bad the result is.
On the example of self-plagiarism, IThenticate Company is a
company that expert in content confirmation technology like, copywriting infringement. The company did
some case studies and researches about copywriting infringements and duplicate
publication. The case studies included academic cases and professional
environments. One of the case studies shows specific case in copywriting
infringements such as technical and medical (STM) journals, including periodicals,
magazines and encyclopedias.
The
company says in the (Self
–plagiarism article) that self-plagiarism become major of the rise. They have
such a larger numbers of articles that many people use duplicate publication. Approximately, 60 % of the
documents have duplicate word or the have the same words in another article
without citation them and put the sources. Also, the largest audiences are from
academic documents, article from the magazine and professional field.
Self –plagiarism is not consider in one
field as I mentation before, also in many field like professional field.
Professional felid is similar such as academic field in self-plagiarism. In
professional society can be a slight different than the academic felid. The
difference that employees use the repots and emails instead of assignments. For
example, the employees probably write a repot in their project and use a report
from different company.
In sum, self-plagiarism cases became more. In fact, my research includes the most important types of Self
–plagiarism, besides all my research comes
from one side that self-plagiarism unethical. Most of the professors and
authors believe that self-plagiarism is bad for the community. Also, it cannot
be helpful for the academic society. And
how the students take any benefits from someone’s idea. The students might not
be like the idea because they think it’s helpful for them. My research based on
the fact that Self –plagiarism is unethical based on the information.
Because what I found id the majority of people agree that self
–plagiarism is unethical and not helpful for the community. In other
side, professional
field self –plagiarism is detrimental. In that case, employees
In
general, self –plagiarism is huge debate weather is unethical or ethical. Most of academic
students see that is ethical, but in the other side; professors see that issue unethical and not good
for the environments. In my opinion self –plagiarism consider to be ethical.
You cannot learn from someone’s idea
I like what American Psychological Association suggest the
following regarding reusing one’s own word. “ When duplication of ones own
words is more extensive, citation of the duplicated words should be norm “and “
must conform to legal notions of fair use.” (Pg.16)
Comments
Post a Comment